Disputed

The McMinnville Photos

Catalog FG-015When May 11, 1950Where Near McMinnville, Oregon

Two farm photos of a disc that have been argued over for 75 years.

Paul Trent took two photographs of a metallic disc over his farm while his wife Evelyn watched. The photos ran in Life magazine. The Condon Committee's photo analyst wrote that the case was one of the few in which every factor seemed consistent with a real, unusual flying object.

Weigh the evidence

The ledger

What the record shows, what people say, and the best explanation available so far.

What's documented

  • The negatives survive and have been analyzed many times.

What's claimed

  • A genuine unknown craft photographed in daylight.

Best explanation so far

Later analysts argue the disc is a small model, possibly a truck mirror, hung from overhead wires. Others defend the photos. Neither side has settled it.

Where to look

Check the sources

Go to the originals. Every link opens the archive or record in a new tab.